Two writing tools, two very different materials
When you want to write without adding more plastic to landfill, the choice often comes down to pencils or pens. But not all eco-friendly options are interchangeable. The ‘Make A Mark’ Recycled Pencils are made from recycled CD cases and contain no wood, while the Paper Ballpoint Pens are made from Kraft paper and stainless steel with zero plastic. Each has a distinct feel, purpose, and pack size that will suit different routines.
This comparison sticks to what the product records confirm, so you can see where each option genuinely fits and where the information runs out.
What each product is actually made of
- ‘Make A Mark’ Recycled Pencils – Red Pack of 3: Made in Worcestershire, UK, from recycled CD cases with no wood at all. If you want a pencil that avoids wood and gives plastic a second life, this is the core appeal.

‘Make A Mark’ Recycled Pencils – Red Pack of 3 - Paper Ballpoint Pens – 24 Pack: Made from Kraft paper and stainless steel, with 100% compostable packaging. The pen body is paper-based and the packaging can break down, which matters if you are trying to avoid plastic entirely.

Paper Ballpoint Pens – 24 Pack
Pack size, price, and what you get
The pencils come as a pack of 3 in red, while the pens come as a 24-pack. That difference alone changes how you might use them: a small pencil pack suits personal use or a small gift, while a 24-pack of pens is better for a classroom, office, or household that loses pens regularly.
- Recycled Pencils – Red Pack of 3: Catalog price USD 2.60 (comparison price USD 4.00). Includes 3 red pencils with a hard graphite grey writing core. Can be sharpened with a traditional sharpener, and the shavings can be recycled.
- Paper Ballpoint Pens – 24 Pack: Catalog price USD 10.21 (comparison price USD 13.98). Includes 24 pens with 58% more ink than standard ballpoint pens, a steel inner tube and nib, and zero plastic.
When recycled pencils make more sense
Choose the ‘Make A Mark’ pencils if you prefer a tool you can sharpen, want a wood-free option, or need a small, affordable pack for doodling, note-taking, or gifting. The hard graphite core is described for writing and sketching, and the red finish with a white logo gives them a distinct look. Because they are made from recycled CD cases, they also appeal to anyone who wants to keep existing plastic in use rather than extracting new materials.
One practical note: the records confirm they can be sharpened with a traditional sharpener, but they do not specify the exact sharpener size or any special care beyond that. If you have a specialty sharpener, test it on one pencil first.
When paper ballpoint pens are the better fit
The Paper Ballpoint Pens suit anyone who needs a larger supply of pens that write like a standard ballpoint but avoid plastic. The 24-pack is sized for sharing, stocking a home office, or supplying a classroom. The steel inner tube and nib are the functional parts, while the Kraft paper outer body is what you see and hold. The pens are described as long-lasting and sturdy, with 58% more ink than standard ballpoints, so they may need replacing less often.
If you need a pen that can be refilled, the records do not confirm refillability, so treat these as disposable after the ink runs out. The packaging is compostable, but the pen itself is not described as compostable—only the paper and steel will break down into natural elements over time.
What the records do not settle
- ‘Make A Mark’ Recycled Pencils – Red Pack of 3: The pencils are made from recycled CD cases and contain no wood, but the records do not state whether the graphite core or the red coating is biodegradable or compostable. If full compostability is a priority, this information is not confirmed by the supplied details.
- Paper Ballpoint Pens – 24 Pack: The pens are described as plastic-free and the packaging is 100% compostable, but the records do not specify a refill option or the exact breakdown time for the stainless steel. This matters if you want a closed-loop product or need to know how long the metal parts persist.
A simple way to decide
If you want a small, sharpened-by-you pencil for writing, sketching, or a pocket-sized gift, the recycled pencils are the straightforward choice. If you need a bulk supply of pens for an office, school, or household, the 24-pack of paper ballpoint pens gives you more units and a familiar writing experience without plastic. Both are sustainable stationery options, but they serve different routines—and neither record claims to be perfect in every environmental category.



