Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-15 Peace With The Wild 9 views

Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil vs Olive Oil: Which to Cook With?

Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil vs Olive Oil: Which to Cook With?

Compare Yorkshire cold-pressed rapeseed oil and extra virgin unfiltered olive oil for frying, roasting and dressings, using only what the product records confirm.

The choice depends on heat, not hype

These two oils are both 500ml bottles from Peace With The Wild, but they are built for different jobs. The Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil record explicitly names frying, roasting, baking, stir-fries, shallow frying and dressings, and describes a high burn point. The Extra Virgin Unfiltered Olive Oil record focuses on cold pressing, unfiltered character and raw flavour, with no cooking temperatures or heat instructions supplied. That difference is the practical starting point: if you want one bottle for the hob and the oven, the rapeseed record gives you more to go on.

Neither record gives a numeric smoke point, so treat 'high burn point' as the manufacturer's wording rather than a laboratory figure. For a direct cooking oil comparison in the UK, the safer approach is to match the oil to the method the record actually supports, then adjust to your own kitchen.

What the Yorkshire rapeseed record confirms

  • Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil – 500ml: Cold-pressed rapeseed oil with a high burn point, described as ideal for frying, roasting, baking, stir-fries, shallow frying and dressings. This is the broadest heat-use evidence in the comparison, making it the more versatile single bottle for cooked food.
    Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil – 500ml
    Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil – 500ml
  • Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil – 500ml: Made from 100% Yorkshire rapeseed grown on the chalky soils of the Yorkshire Wolds, with a delicate nutty flavour. The flavour is described as delicate rather than neutral, so it will contribute a nutty note to roast vegetables, pastries and dressings.
  • Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil – 500ml: Once opened, store in a cool dry place; do not refrigerate; keep away from direct sunlight. These are the only storage instructions supplied, and they matter more than the bottle size when you are deciding where the oil will live.

What the olive oil record confirms

  • Extra Virgin Unfiltered Olive Oil – 500ml: Extra virgin, unfiltered and unblended oil made from Koroneiki olives, cold-pressed immediately after harvesting in small batches. The record positions this as a flavour-first finishing oil, not a general-purpose frying oil.
    Extra Virgin Unfiltered Olive Oil – 500ml
    Extra Virgin Unfiltered Olive Oil – 500ml
  • Extra Virgin Unfiltered Olive Oil – 500ml: The record describes antioxidants and heart-healthy monounsaturated fats, and links the oil to the Mediterranean diet. These are the manufacturer's general descriptions, not a personal health recommendation; they explain why someone might choose it for raw use.
  • Extra Virgin Unfiltered Olive Oil – 500ml: Packaged in a reusable glass bottle; no opening or storage instructions are supplied in the record. Because storage guidance is not confirmed here, do not assume the same cool, dark rules as the rapeseed bottle without checking the label.

Frying, roasting and dressings side by side

Use this as a job-by-job guide, not a league table. Where the record is silent, the honest answer is that the evidence does not settle it.

  • Frying and shallow frying: The rapeseed record explicitly lists frying and shallow frying and claims a high burn point. The olive oil record gives no frying instruction, so it is not confirmed for this job.
  • Roasting and baking: Rapeseed is named for roasting, baking and pastries. Olive oil is not described for oven use in the supplied record, so choose it for roasting only if you are comfortable relying on your own experience rather than the listing.
  • Dressings and raw finishing: Both records support raw use in principle: rapeseed is listed for dressings, and the olive oil is presented as a cold-pressed, unfiltered oil with a distinctive taste. The olive oil's stronger flavour will show more in a vinaigrette; the rapeseed's nutty note is described as delicate.
  • Everyday value: The catalog prices are USD 2.48 for the 500ml rapeseed oil and USD 11.09 for the 500ml olive oil. If you want one bottle to cover most cooking, the rapeseed is the lower-cost route; the olive oil costs more per bottle for a specialist raw oil.

Storage and handling differences that affect your choice

  • Rapeseed: cool, dry, dark: The record says to store it in a cool dry place once opened, keep it away from direct sunlight and not refrigerate it. That rules out the fridge door and a sunny windowsill.
  • Olive oil: check the bottle: The supplied record does not include opening or storage instructions. Rather than copy the rapeseed rules across, follow the label on the bottle you receive.
  • Both are 500ml glass bottles: The rapeseed uses a reusable glass bottle with a metal screw cap; the olive oil also comes in a reusable glass bottle. Neither record gives a shelf life after opening, so do not invent one.

A simple way to decide

If you want one bottle for frying, roasting, baking and dressings, the Yorkshire Rapeseed Oil is the better-supported choice because its record names those uses and a high burn point. If you mainly want a cold-pressed, unfiltered olive oil for dressings and raw finishing, and you are willing to check the bottle's own storage guidance, the Extra Virgin Unfiltered Olive Oil is the flavour-led option. Buying both is reasonable if you cook with heat often and also want a distinctive finishing oil, but it is not necessary to make either one work.

One limitation worth stating plainly: the records do not give numeric smoke points, exact harvest dates or a full nutrition panel. Those gaps mean you should not treat this comparison as a laboratory ranking. Use the stated uses, the storage instructions where supplied, and your own cooking results to decide which bottle earns counter space.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile